A Woman’s Advantage
The secret to success for women on OkCupid? Sending the first message.
If you’ve ever dated anyone, you know that dating inherently (er, ideally) involves people with a mutual interest in each other. But to get things started, someone has to make the first move. In the physical world, maybe that means a subtle wink. Or presenting the other with an elaborately carved spoon. In online dating, it’s all about likes, swipes, and sending the first message.
Traditionally, men take the initiative. At least that’s what we can discern from most examples of romance in Western culture. On OkCupid however, women and men exhibit similar behavior when it comes to liking, browsing and having conversations. The playing field is also pretty even: there are 1.5 men for every woman on the site. These women are progressive too, with 43 percent of women preferring to split the check (compared to 17 percent of men).
Yet there is one crucial way in which women fail to take the lead. Most women — regardless of sexual orientation — do not send the first message, with straight woman 3.5x less likely to compared to straight men.
So we asked ourselves: why are ladies — in particular, straight women — less likely to spark a conversation?
You’ve got a ton of mail
At first, we thought that women could be more passive because they get a lot of attention. If you’re a woman who dates online, you’ve probably sifted through a lot of messages. Some are sincere. Others are direct references to penises. Rarely do the two collide:
So how does the quantity of messages received affect women? Could it be that women with fuller inboxes don’t feel the need to send messages, and those who don’t receive many messages send more?
Shockingly, no. The number of messages received doesn’t affect how many messages women send out. Even if a woman receives zero, 10 or 20 messages, she’s not likely to send more. On the contrary, men initiate no matter what, and the more messages they receive, the more they send.
No age limit
When we looked at age, we thought we might see some trends around how women behave — do older women act more assertively because they’re more confident? Are they more likely to reach out because they’re more particular about what they want?
Turns out age doesn’t really matter, either. Generally speaking: young or old, your outboxes are empty. Men, however, message most between the ages of 20 to 40.
Hey, ur hot!
Let’s be clear: on OkCupid, your attractiveness rank isn’t just about looks — you need great photos and an interesting profile to get more likes and boost your standing. What if we proposed that women who rank more attractively feel like they don’t need to reach out first? Perhaps they’re used to getting attention, so they prefer to wait to be courted.
No matter how attractive a woman appears, we see similar messaging behavior. For men, those who are most attractive send the most messages, with the top 40% reaching out the most. Perhaps they enjoy basking in the glory of being one of the elitely attractive.
At this point, we’re perplexed. Women rarely reach out, no matter their circumstances. Yet doing this research unlocked a secret — the OkCupid ecosystem actually puts women at a huge advantage.
The truth about messaging
When we looked specifically at sending the first message, we found one striking habit: everyone’s a reacher, meaning people tend to reach out to someone more attractive than they are. To put a number on it, men are reaching out to women 17 percentile points more attractive, and women contact men who are 10 percentile points more attractive. This means that if a woman does nothing, her inbox will be filled with less attractive men.
A simple adjustment
If a woman sends the first message, everything changes in her favor.
That’s because men tend to respond, a lot. In fact, women are 2.5x more likely to get a response than men if they initiate. If you’re a woman who sends the first message, not only are you more likely to get more responses in general, but you’ll be having conversations with more attractive guys.
Shoot for the moon
Most women on OkCupid are still waiting to be messaged, which means they’re settling and not even realizing it. Let’s break that down: based on what we know, if you’re a woman and receive a message, the man who sent it is about 5 percentile points less attractive than you. But if you send the first hello, the man is about 7 percentile points more attractive than you. So if you typically wait to be approached, you could elevate your game by about 12 percent points just by sending the first message.
Those sending the first message are already getting results. If all women sent more messages, would they get more responses? We can’t objectively say yes, but that’s the case of the site right now.
Ladies’ choice
If you’re a woman on OkCupid, you’re at an incredible advantage. You should message men you find attractive — not just because they’re easy on the eye, but because you’re more likely to have something to talk about. You’ll increase your quantity of quality. As for men, it’s worth noting that they’ll probably enjoy getting more messages.
The odds are in your favor. What’s the worst that could happen? You message a cute guy and don’t get an answer. What’s the best? That’s between you and your date.
Want to be a part of this report, and future ones? Sign up for OkCupid.
Written by Kelly Cooper. Data Science by Dale Markowitz. Header illustration by Shawna X. Designed by Shane Zucker.
We know you’re more substance than just selfie. Give OkCupid a try to connect with people as individual as you are.
